You know what? I went in thinking I’d just hit a few fairways, stare at the water, and call it good. But Sugar Bay gave me more. It gave me wind, nerves, and a couple of sweet pars that I’m still talking about in the car.
First look and first swing
I pulled up for a late morning tee time. Parking was easy. The pro shop felt small but friendly. I grabbed a cart, a sleeve of Pro V1s, and a banana. The starter joked about the breeze off the bay. “It’s playful,” he said. He was half right.
The range was open but a bit beat up. The practice green rolled medium. Not slow. Not fast. I’d call it fair. My first swing with my TaylorMade driver found the right rough. Not bad for me. Not great, but not bad.
The front nine: room to breathe
The front nine feels open. It gives you space. You can see trouble, but it doesn’t shout. Hole 3 is a short par 4 with a dogleg left. You can lay up with a 5-iron, then wedge in. Or you can try to cut the corner. I tried to cut it. Landed in a bunker. Soft sand, good lie, easy splash out. Still made bogey. I wasn’t mad. That hole is fun.
Hole 6 stood out. A par 3 over the bay. It’s not long, but the crosswind makes your brain buzz. I hit a knockdown 8-iron. Kept it low. It bounced short, rolled on, and stopped pin-high. Two putts. Par. I smiled like a kid. That shot felt clean. If you’d like to see the hole graphics and read how other players tackled it, GolfDigest has a solid breakdown.
The back nine: tighter and a little meaner
The back nine plays snug by the marsh. You hear birds. You feel the air get heavy. Hole 13 is a par 5 that runs along the edge. If you chase it, you can reach in two. I didn’t. I laid up to 90 yards. Sand wedge to 12 feet. Missed the putt on the low side. Here’s a tip: putts break toward the bay more than you think.
Hole 16 is a short par 3 with a two-tier green. Miss on the wrong level and you’ll two-putt from anywhere. Maybe three. I spun a pitching wedge back off the shelf. That one hurt. Bogey city.
Conditions: the good, the not-so-good
- Fairways: Mostly lush. A few thin spots near 12 and 15. Nothing wild.
- Greens: Medium speed. Rolling true on most holes. A little bumpy on 14.
- Bunkers: Fluffy, which I like. One fairway bunker was firm and crusty.
- Cart paths: Some cracks, some dust. Still fine to drive.
- Water jugs: Full. Cold. Bless them.
For current course conditions, slope ratings, and recent reviews, check the listing on GolfPass.
I did see a gator in the marsh by 11. Small guy. He minded his business. I minded mine.
Pace, people, and price
We played in about 4 hours and 15 minutes on a Saturday. The marshal kept folks moving without being pushy. The starter gave wind tips. The cart kid wiped my windshield at the turn. Nice touch.
I paid $89 with a cart at noon. The group behind me said twilight was $59. Good value for the views and the layout. The snack bar burger was juicy, and the fries were hot. Mahi tacos had a kick. Bring napkins.
My gear and what actually worked
I used my TaylorMade Stealth driver, a 5-wood off the deck on 13, and my trusty 54-degree for most chips. Bushnell rangefinder helped in the wind. Arccos tags said I gained strokes with wedges. Lost a couple with the putter. Not news.
Wind play mattered here. Keep the ball low. Tee it a hair lower. Smooth swing. Let the breeze be a friend, not a fight.
Little things that stuck with me
- The smell of salt near 6 and 7.
- A heron that watched my whole approach on 9 like a judge.
- A kid on the patio, swinging a cut-off 7-iron, grinning at nothing and everything.
- Sunscreen didn’t save my neck. Wear a hat with a flap on hot days.
- Gnats showed up near dusk. Bug spray helped.
Tips if you go
- Bring extra balls. The bay doesn’t give them back.
- Aim a touch right on 6 if the wind is left to right.
- Putts leak toward the water. It’s real.
- Walkable? Yes, but it gets warm. A cart makes sense on a sunny day.
- Check for cart-path-only after rain. The turf holds water by the marsh.
- Looking to linger longer? The adjoining Sugar Bay Resort and Spa lets you swap spikes for slippers the moment you step off 18.
After the scorecards are signed, some traveling golfers want more than a beer on the patio—if you’re in the mood to meet new people fast, the hookup-friendly platform MeetnFuck connects adults in the area so you can line up a no-strings rendezvous before you head home. If your trip has you cruising further up the coast toward Craven County, the curated classifieds at Backpage New Bern showcase real-time local personal ads and events, giving you a quick way to connect with like-minded company for drinks, dinner, or whatever adventure you’ve got in mind.
Who will love it
Mid-handicaps will have a blast. New golfers won’t feel trapped, but the wind can spook you. Low handicaps can chase numbers on calm mornings. Couples and friends will like the patio after the round. It’s relaxed. Nobody acts fancy.
The rough spots
A few rough cart paths. That one hard bunker. Some patchy turf on the back nine. The range could use fresh turf and better balls. None of it broke the day, but it’s worth a note.
Final take
Sugar Bay isn’t perfect. It’s honest. The bay adds drama. The layout asks smart questions. The wind talks to you. Some holes hug you. Some push back. I made two pars that felt like birdies, and one bogey that felt fair. I’d go again, no doubt.
Scorecard feeling? A steady 4 out of 5. Bring shade, bring patience, and bring a shot you can trust when the breeze starts to laugh.


