The island edit

The short answer: An old Sugar Bay listing does not prove that rooms are open. A July 2025 government report said the hotel might reopen in late 2026. That is a plan, not proof that guests can stay. For an all-inclusive trip to St. Thomas, start with Bolongo Bay Beach Resort. Check rooms for your dates before you book flights.

The short answer: Choose Buoy Haus if easy beach access is your first wish. Choose Westin for a larger resort with more pool choices. Both sit at Frenchman's Reef, but Buoy Haus guests get broader access across the two properties.

The short answer: The Ritz-Carlton, St. Thomas makes the most sense for guests who will use its pools, beach, spa, and Club Lounge. It is harder to justify if you plan to spend most days out. Compare the full room bill and Club Level cost before paying for the name.

The short answer: Start with Bolongo Bay Beach Resort for a small, all-ages stay on St. Thomas. Choose Carina Bay on St. Croix if everyone is 18 or older and you want an adults-only break. Check the exact meal plan before booking: breakfast, a dining credit, and Club Level are not the same as all-inclusive.